Skip To Main Content
A woman in a white lab coat using a microscope in a laboratory setting.

Efficacy Studies

Learn about the efficacy of Thyrogen as an adjunct to radioactive iodine (RAI) ablation and diagnostic testing

As an adjunct to radioactive iodine (RAI) ablation of thyroid tissue remnants

Thyrogen was compared with thyroid hormone withdrawal (THW) using 2 different doses of radioiodine in patients with well-differentiated thyroid cancer who had undergone thyroidectomy. To date, these are the 2 largest, prospective, multicenter, randomized studies performed in thyroid cancer.1,2

  • In both studies, patients were randomized to 1 of 4 treatment groups: Thyrogen + 30 mCi, Thyrogen + 100 mCi, THW + 30 mCi, THW +100 mCi. There was no difference in the treatment success rates between the 2 doses of radioiodine.
  • Ablation success rates were assessed at approximately 8 months.

The two studies compared the following:

  • Safety and Ablation efficacy between patients prepared with Thyrogen and thyroid hormone withdrawal (THW)
  • Symptoms of acute hypothyroidism before, during, and after Thyrogen injections and thyroid hormone withdrawal (THW).
  • Recurrence rates 5 years after radioactive iodine treatment

What You Should Know About the Adult Patients in These Studies1-4

 

Five blue-outlined circles display study data with purple and black text: the first shows 1,150 patients studied in 2 prospective randomized trials with a purple-outlined three-person icon; the second shows 100% had well-differentiated thyroid cancer (papillary and follicular), represented by a purple-outlined microscope icon; the third shows 99% had total/total thyroidectomy, represented by a purple-outlined surgical scissors and scalpel icon; the fourth shows >90% most patients had low to intermediate risk thyroid cancer, represented by green and red person icons; and the fifth shows 30mCI/100mCI low and high iodine was studied, represented by a purple-outlined capsule icon.


Exclusion criteria were the presence of aggressive malignant variants, including tall-cell, insular, poorly differentiated, and diffuse sclerosing thyroid cancer; anaplastic or medullary carcinoma; pregnancy; severe coexisting conditions; previous cancer with limited life expectancy; previous iodine-131 or iodine-123 preablation scanning (contamination); and previous treatment for thyroid cancer except surgery.1,2

Ablation Success at 8 Months: Data from the 2 largest, randomized clinical trials in differentiated thyroid cancer1,2

Bar chart comparing the percentage of patients in two groups: Thyrogen (183/210) and THW (Thyroid Hormone Withdrawal) (183/211), with the y-axis ranging from 0% to 100%. Both groups are represented by bars, purple for Thyrogen and blue for THW each showing a value of 87%.

Successful remnant ablation rates (HiLo Study1): Randomized 438 patients (tumor stages T1-T3, Nx, N0 and N1, M0)

Bar chart comparing the percentage of patients in two groups: Thyrogen (319/348) and THW (Thyroid Hormone Withdrawal) (312/336), with the y-axis ranging from 0% to 100%. The Thyrogen group is represented by a purple bar showing 92%, and the THW group by a blue bar showing 93%.

Successful remnant ablation rates (ESTIMABL Study2): randomized 752 low risk patients

In pooled studies from 6 clinical studies, the most common side effects in patients were nausea, headache, fatigue, vomiting, dizziness and asthenia.5

In a study with 63 patients, researchers evaluated the quality of life across eight areas using the SF-36 Scale.6

  • The Short-Form 36-Item Health Survey (SF-36) is a clinically validated assessment tool commonly used in clinical trials. A higher score indicates a better response.
  • The scores were taken at baseline, 2 weeks after randomization, and immediately before RAI ablation for all patients who were randomized into two trial arms: Thyrogen and thyroid hormone withdrawal (THW) plus 100 mCI radioactive iodine.
  • The Quality of Life in patients following Thyrogen administration improved in 7of 8 domains between baseline and week 4, whereas the THW group experienced a decrease in 7 of 8 QOL measures.
     

Mean change in SF-36 scores from baseline to week 46


Patients prepared with Thyrogen improved in seven of eight physical and mental domains between baseline and week 4.

The Short-Form 36-Item Health Survey (SF-36) is a clinically validated assessment tool commonly used in clinical trials. A higher score indicates a better response.

Horizontal bar chart compares the mean difference for the Thyrogen group (purple bars, n=33) and the THW group (dark blue bars, n=30). The y-axis represents domains: Physical Functioning, Role-Physical, Bodily Pain, General Health, Vitality, Social Functioning, Role emotional, and Mental Health. The x-axis represents scores from -20 to 20. The Thyrogen group shows positive differences (improvement) in all eight domains, ranging from approximately 5 to 15, while the THW group shows negative differences (decline) in all domains. The P values listed on the far right of the chart are: P=0.016 for Physical Functioning, P=0.018 for Role-Physical, P=NS for Bodily Pain, General Health and Role emotional, P<0.0001 for Vitality and Social Functioning and P=0.002 for Mental Health. A legend at the bottom indicates bar colors.

In the HiLO and ESTIMABL studies, Thyrogen patients had their cancer return at a similar rate as patients who underwent thyroid hormone withdrawal (THW) after radioactive iodine (RAI) ablation.3,4

 

Long-term follow-up results from 2 large studies (1150 patients) on thyroid cancer show that Thyrogen had similar results compared with THW for radioactive iodine ablation.

  • Cancer recurrence was similar across patients in the Thyrogen and THW groups.1,2
  • Overall patients receiving Thyrogen, demonstrated lower deterioration of HRQoL scores compared to those who experienced THW. This is because Thyrogen may help lower the symptoms associated with acute hypothyroidism.

 

Results of two clinical studies showed that at 5 years recurrence rates after RAI ablation are similar between Thyrogen and thyroid hormone withdrawal (THW)

In low-risk well differentiated thyroid cancer (WDTC) patients, less than 2% had their cancer return at 5 years3

In the ESTIMABL study with 726 patients who received RAI, outcomes were comparable in the different patient groups. Among the patients who had their cancer return, 7 (1.9%) received Thyrogen and 4 (1.1%) received THW.1

Bar graph shows the percentage of patients with recurrence at 5 years on the y-axis, ranging from 0 to 100. A horizontal bar is drawn near the 0%, with a large purple arrow pointing down to it. The arrow contains the text: "Less than 2% had their cancer return," indicating a very low recurrence rate.

In low to intermediate risk well differentiated thyroid cancer patients, cancer recurrence rates were similar between those who received Thyrogen vs THW at 5 years4

In the HiLO study with 438 patients who received RAI, disease recurrence rates were similar among patients in the Thyrogen group vs those in the THW group (2.1% vs. 2.7%).2

Percentage of patients with recurrence at 5 years

Bar chart comparing the percentage of patients in two groups: Thyrogen and Thyroid Hormone Withdrawal, with the y-axis ranging from 0.0% to 3.0%. The Thyrogen group is represented by a purple bar at 2.1%, while the Thyroid Hormone Withdrawal group is shown by a blue bar at 2.7%.

Thyrogen patients reported better physical and psychological function than those who experienced thyroid hormone withdrawal (THW)

Thyrogen patients had better quality of life compared with THW while undergoing preparation for ablation.

In the HiLo study with 438 patients, quality of life was evaluated at the time of consent, on the day of ablation before radioiodine administration, and 3 months after ablation.

Before ablation, among patients receiving Thyrogen, there were clear benefits as compared with those undergoing THW for physical and psychological functioning.3*

*The difference between treatment groups was statistically significant (p<0.0001) for all eight QOL domains, favoring Thyrogen over thyroid hormone withdrawal. In the remnant ablation study, following thyroid hormone withdrawal, statistically significant negative changes were noted in five of the eight QOL domains (physical functioning, role physical, vitality, social functioning and mental health).3

Bar chart with a title reading "Mean difference in the Short Form (SF)-36 scores at the time of consent and on the day of ablation2". The y-axis ranges from -30 to 20 in increments of 5, representing the mean difference in scores. The x-axis includes two categories: "All Physical Domains" and "All Psychological Domains." Under "All Physical Domains," a purple bar representing Thyrogen extends upward to a value of 11, while a blue bar representing THW extends downward to -19. Under "All Psychological Domains," the Thyrogen bar rises to 13.1, and the THW bar drops to -25.2. A legend at the bottom indicates that purple represents Thyrogen and blue represents THW.

Fewer Thyrogen patients reported having difficulty performing their usual activities at home and work

On the day of ablation, patients also completed a questionnaire about thyroid cancer–specific symptoms.

In patients reporting symptoms as either "moderate" or "a lot" fewer Thyrogen patients had difficulty performing usual household activities (13.2% vs 19.2%) or taking care of their children (8.1% vs 14.1%) compared to patients undergoing THW. Among the patients who were employed, fewer patients in the Thyrogen group had difficulty performing usual activities at work compared with the THW group (9.4% vs 22.1%).3

In the same study, out of 438 patients1

Table comparing the percentage of patients reporting symptoms between the Thyrogen and THW treatment groups. For the symptom "Difficulty in performing usual activities at home," 13.2% of the Thyrogen group reported it, compared to 19.2% in the THW group. "Difficulty in taking care of children at homea" was reported by 8.1% of the Thyrogen group and 14.5% of the THW group. Finally, "Difficulty in performing usual activities at workb" was reported by 9.4% of patients in the Thyrogen group versus 22.1% in the THW group. The text below reads 'aBased on responses from 87 patients in the Thyrogen group and 76 patients in the THW group.' 'bBased on responses from 139 patients in the Thyrogen group and 136 patients in the THW group.' 'Percentage of patients reporting symptoms as either "moderate" or "a lot" Adapted from Mallick U, et al, 2012.'

As an adjunct to diagnostic testing with a whole body scan (WBS) and/or a thyroglobulin blood test

What You Should Know About the Adult Patients in These Studies4,5,7†

 

Four blue-outlined circles display study data: the first shows 356 patients studied in 2 prospective randomized trials with a purple-outlined three person icon; the second shows 99% has total/total thyroidectomy, represented by a purple-outlined surgical scissors and scalpel icon; the third shows 100% had well-differentiated thyroid cancer including papillary, follicular and Hurthle cell, represented with a purple-outlined microscope icon; and the fourth indicates the majority of patients followed a low iodine diet, represented by a purple-outlined apple icon.


†In the HiLo trial, patients were excluded if they had aggressive thyroid cancer variants, anaplastic or medullary carcinoma, pregnancy, severe comorbidities, prior malignancy with limited life expectancy, previous pre-ablation radioiodine scanning, or prior thyroid cancer treatment other than surgery. In Haugen et al., exclusions included concurrent major medical disorder, contrast agent exposure, failure to achieve adequate TSH suppression, or prior radioiodine therapy within 4 months of enrolment. Non - well differentiated tumor histology, and patients who had potential for iodine contamination.4,7,8

The two studies compared the following:5,7

  • Radioactive iodine whole body scans (WBS) obtained after THYROGEN injections and radioactive iodine whole body scans after thyroid hormone withdrawal (THW).
  • Combination of stimulated thyroglobulin (Tg) levels in the blood and WBS obtained after THYROGEN injections and after thyroid hormone withdrawal (THW).
  • Symptoms of acute hypothyroidism before, during, and after Thyrogen injections and thyroid hormone withdrawal (THW).‡

‡One of the studies with 229 patients, also compared the quality of life between the Thyrogen phase and the THW phase.7

RESULTS comparing patients who received THYROGEN with those prepared with thyroid hormone withdrawal for radioiodine Whole Body Scanning With or Without stimulated thyroglobulin blood testing5,7

Two mirrored profiles of a person's head and neck, with colors indicating temperature (red/orange for warmer areas like the face, green and blue for cooler areas) separated by a white, circled approximately equal to symbol (=).

Disease detection rates were found to be comparable to the scans after Thyrogen and scans after thyroid hormone withdrawal with or without thyroglobulin testing

Icon of a test tube with a cap and a document featuring a droplet, both outlined in blue.

 

In two diagnostic studies, researchers evaluated the signs and symptoms of acute hypothyroidism in patients who received 2 injections of Thyrogen compared to by THW.5,7,8 The Billewicz scale was used.

A Billewicz scale is an observer-rated set of clinical findings that has been widely used in assessing hypothyroidism. Higher scores are associated with an increase in signs and symptoms of hypothyroidism.

Billewicz scores were taken at baseline while on thyroid hormone therapy, after administration of Thyrogen and after THW on day of RAI administration

Statistically significant worsening in all measured signs and symptoms were observed during the acute hypothyroid phase for patients undergoing THW

  • Thyrogen is given as a 0.9 mg injection into the muscle of the buttock for two consecutive days
  • The most common side effects in patients getting Thyrogen were nausea, headache, fatigue, vomiting, dizziness and asthenia
Bar chart comparing the sum of Billewicz scores for various symptoms across three phases: Pre-Treatment Phase (light grey), Thyrogen (purple), and Withdrawal Phase (dark blue). The x-axis ranges from 0 to 180 and is labeled from "Poorest Health" on the left to "Best Health" on the right. The y-axis lists symptoms: Diminished Sweating, Dry Skin, Cold Intolerance, Weight Increase, Constipation, Hoarseness, Paresthesia, Deafness, Slow Movements, Coarse Skin, Cold Skin, Periorbital Puffiness, Slowing of Ankle Jerk, and Decreased Pulse. In nearly all cases, the Withdrawal Phase (dark blue bars) shows the highest Billewicz scores, indicating worse health, with Periorbital Puffiness and Cold Intolerance being the most affected. The Thyrogen Phase scores are generally lower, indicating better health than those in both the Pre-Treatment and Withdrawal Phases. A legend at the bottom indicates bar colors.

Thyrogen administration was associated with fewer signs and symptoms of hypothyroidism than those associated with thyroid hormone withdrawal as measured by the Billewicz scale.

The Quality of Life in patients following Thyrogen administration in the trial remained similar to their scores before the start of the trial when they were still on thyroid hormone medication.


In one diagnostic study with 229 patients, researchers evaluated quality of life across eight areas using the SF-36 Scale.7

The SF-36 is a 36-item, patient- Best Health reported survey of patient health, consisting of eight scaled scores. The lower the score the more disability. The higher the score the less the disability.

The scores were taken at 3 points in time. At baseline while patients were still on their thyroid hormone medication, after administration of Thyrogen and after TWH on the day of RAI administration.

In this study, patients rated their QOL higher in all eight areas while using Thyrogen to prepare for RAI versus when they underwent THW in preparation for ablation. In fact, in this trial, with 229 patients, the quality of life differences in all eight domains was considered statistically significant.

SF-36 Health Survey Results in the Thyrogen Diagnostic Trial with 229 patients7

 

Bar chart comparing summary scores for different health and functioning domains. The x-axis shows scores from 0 to 100, explicitly labeled as &quot;Poorest Health&quot; on the left and &quot;Best Health&quot; on the right. The y-axis lists the domains: Physical Functioning, Role Functioning, Bodily Pain, General Health, Vitality, Social Functioning, Role Emotional, and Mental Health across three treatment phases: Pre-Treatment Phase (light grey), Thyrogen (purple), and Withdrawal Phase (dark blue). For all eight domains, the Thyrogen phase records the highest scores, near or above 80, indicating better health, while the Withdrawal Phase shows the lowest scores, especially in domains like Role Emotional and Vitality. A legend at the bottom indicates bar colors.

Quality of life differences in all eight domains was statistically significant

References

  1. Mallick U, Harmer C, Yap B, et al. Ablation with low-dose radioiodine and thyrotropin alfa in thyroid cancer. N Engl J Med. 2012;366(18):1674-1685.
  2. Schlumberger M, Catargi B, Borget I, et al. Strategies of radioiodine ablation in patients with low-risk thyroid cancer. N Engl J Med. 2012;366(18):1663-1673.
  3. Schlumberger M, Leboulleux S, Catargi B, et al. Outcome after ablation in patients with low-risk thyroid cancer (ESTIMABL1): 5-year follow-up results of a randomised, phase 3, equivalence trial. Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol. 2018;6(8):618-626.
  4. Dehbi HM, Mallick U, Wadsley J, Newbold K, Harmer C, Hackshaw A. Recurrence after low-dose radioiodine ablation and recombinant human thyroid-stimulating hormone for differentiated thyroid cancer (HiLo): long-term results of an open-label, non-inferiority randomised controlled trial. Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol. 2019;7(1):44-51.
  5. Thyrogen (thyrotropin alfa for injection) Prescribing Information. Genzyme Corporation. February 2023.
  6. Pacini F, Ladenson PW, Schlumberger M, et al. Radioiodine ablation of thyroid remnants after preparation with recombinant human thyrotropin in differentiated thyroid carcinoma: results of an international, randomized, controlled study. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2006;91(3):926-932.
  7. Haugen BR, Pacini F, Reiners C, et al. A comparison of recombinant human thyrotropin and thyroid hormone withdrawal for the detection of thyroid remnant or cancer. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1999;84(11):3877-3885.
  8. Ladenson PW, Braverman LE, Mazzaferri EL, et al. Comparison of administration of recombinant human thyrotropin with withdrawal of thyroid hormone for radioactive iodine scanning in patients with thyroid carcinoma. N Engl J Med. 1997;337(13):888-896.

Important Safety Information and Indication

Thyrogen (thyrotropin alfa) is used to help identify thyroid disease by testing the blood for a hormone called thyroglobulin in the follow up of patients with a certain type of thyroid cancer known as well differentiated thyroid cancer. It is used with or without a radiology test using a form of iodine.

Limitations of Use:

  • The effect of Thyrogen on long term thyroid cancer outcomes has not been determined.
  • When Thyrogen is used to help detect thyroid cancer, there is still a chance all or parts of the cancer could be missed.

Thyrogen is also used to help patients prepare for treatment with a form of iodine, called radioiodine, to remove leftover thyroid tissue in patients who have had surgery to take out the entire thyroid gland for patients with well differentiated thyroid cancer who do not have signs of thyroid cancer which has spread to other parts of the body.

Limitations of Use:

  • In a study of people being prepared for treatment with a form of iodine after thyroid surgery, results were similar between those who received Thyrogen and those who stopped taking their thyroid hormone for up to 5 years after treatment. Researchers do not know if results would be similar over a longer period of time.

Patients should not use Thyrogen with radioiodine if they have a contraindication to the use of radioiodine. Please consult with your doctor for a list of contraindications for radioiodine.

Thyrogen can cause serious side effects, including:

Thyrogen-Induced Hyperthyroidism:

  • There have been reports of events that led to death in patients who have not had surgery to have their thyroid gland removed, and in patients with thyroid cancer cells that have spread to other parts of the body.
  • Patients over 65 years old with large amounts of leftover thyroid tissue after surgery, or with a history of heart disease, should discuss with their physicians the risks and benefits of Thyrogen.
  • Thyrogen can be administered in the hospital for patients at risk for complications from Thyrogen administration.

Stroke:

  • Since Thyrogen was first approved for use, there have been reports of central nervous system problems such as stroke in young women who have a higher chance of having a stroke, and weakness on one side of the body. The relationship between THYROGEN administration and stroke is unknown. Patients should remain hydrated prior to treatment with Thyrogen.

Sudden Rapid Tumor Enlargement:

  •  Leftover thyroid tissue after surgery and cancer cells that have spread to other parts of the body can quickly grow and become painful after Thyrogen administration. Patients with cancer cells near their windpipe, in their central nervous system, or in their lungs may need treatment with a glucocorticoid (a medication to help prevent an increase in the size of the cancer cells before using Thyrogen.)

Risks Associated with Radioiodine Treatment: 

  • If THYROGEN is administered with radioiodine (RAI), the serious side effects for RAI apply to this combination regimen. Please consult with your doctor for a list of contraindications for radioiodine. 

ADVERSE REACTIONS

In clinical studies, the most common side effects reported were nausea and headache.

USE IN SPECIFIC PATIENT POPULATIONS

Pregnant patients: Notify your healthcare provider immediately in the event of a pregnancy. If THYROGEN is administered with radioiodine, the combination regimen should not be used in pregnant women. Thyrogen should be given to a pregnant woman only if the doctor thinks there is a clear need for it.

Breastfeeding patients: If THYROGEN is administered with radioiodine, the combination regimen should not be used in breastfeeding women. It is not known whether Thyrogen can appear in human milk. Breastfeeding women should discuss the benefits and risks of Thyrogen with their physician.

Children: Safety and effectiveness in young patients (under the age of 18) have not been established.

Elderly: Studies do not show a difference in the safety and effectiveness of Thyrogen between adult patients less than 65 years and those over 65 years of age.

Patients with kidney disease: Thyrogen exits the body much slower in dialysis patients and can lead to longer high TSH levels.

 

Click here for full Prescribing Information including Serious Side Effects.

Click here for full Patient Information including Serious Side Effects.

Click here to learn more about Sanofi’s commitment to fighting counterfeit drugs.